Ask FELTG
Have a question about federal employment law? Read below to find answers - or ask a question of your own.MSPB Only Has 2 Members; What Happens if They Don’t Agree on the Outcome?
As the FELTG newsletter reader pointed out, the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) is currently down a member. So what happens if the two remaining members can't agree on the outcome of a Petition for Review (PFR)? It's a great question. And here's our answer. If...
Ask FELTG: Is There Case Law That Warns Against Alternative Discipline?
Much like the Merit Systems Protection Board, we at FELTG are longtime proponents of alternative discipline. And why not? In many cases, alternative sanctions are the more effective approach when addressing misconduct. Not too long ago, we received the following...
ASK FELTG: Does union rep have right to attend staff meeting whenever he wants?
Here’s a summarized version of the question that came into FELTG headquarters: I run a monthly staff meeting with the employees I supervise. They are bargaining unit employees. I received a request from a union rep to attend the staff meetings. I asked him the nature...
Ask FELTG: If an employee is AWOL, should agency charge only AWOL or also Failure to Follow Leave procedures?
June 26, 2023 Thanks for the question; it’s one we get fairly frequently. Let’s look at what the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) says on this matter: AWOL and Failure to Follow Leave Procedures generally are separate charges with different elements of proof....
Ask FELTG: Does a Local CBA Trump an Agency’s Nationwide Policy?
June 14, 2023 Here’s more context from the loyal FELTG reader who posed the question: Let’s say, hypothetically, management at a regional outpost agrees to terms regarding office workspace with their local union, and then enters into a CBA articulating those...
Ask FELTG: If an employee is out of leave and requests Leave Without Pay for an ongoing illness, is the agency required to grant the LWOP?
Thanks for the question. And the answer is … it depends. A foundational principle regarding LWOP is that granting or denying LWOP is within the agency’s discretion. See Sambrano v. Department of Defense, 116 M.S.P.R. 449, ¶ 4 (2011). In cases involving employee...
Ask FELTG: Could Last Chance Agreement Open Agency to Disparate Treatment Claim?
The following question came into the FELTG mailroom. Our agency sometimes uses Last Chance Agreements, but a few members of leadership are concerned that offering LCAs to only certain people could open the agency up to claims of disparate treatment discrimination....
Ask FELTG: I work for a fairly small agency. Is it a problem if the same supervisor acts as both the Proposing and Deciding Official in a disciplinary action?
You might be surprised by this, but the answer is no – it’s not a problem or issue as long as the employee is given due process: 1. Proposal notice with charge(s), penalty, and the material relied upon in making the proposal; 2. An opportunity to respond orally and in...
Ask FELTG: What’s the Best Way to Calculate Non-pecuniary Compensatory Damages in an EEO Case?
February 28, 2023 Thanks for the question. The best way to determine appropriate compensatory damages in cases where agencies are found liable for discrimination, harassment, reprisal, or a failure to accommodate is to look at the harm the employee endured. It’s...
Ask FELTG Tackles Accommodation Request for Inability to Commute
Here's a question that recently came into FELTG's mailroom: In granting or denying a reasonable accommodation request for telework, does it make any difference if the employee’s only disability-related problem is his commute to work? Hypothetically, he does not have...